Core Refusal Reason
The proposed development constitutes overdevelopment of a constrained site due to excessive height, massing, and a poor internal layout that fails to integrate with the surrounding context or protect the residential amenities of adjacent properties.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The excessive height and massing of the development fail to provide a successful scale transition between the contemporary Ros Ard complex and the lower-rise historic townhouses to the east.
- The proposal creates a significant negative impact on the residential amenities of neighboring properties (Nos. 7, 9, and 11 Rosemount Lane) through direct overlooking from east-facing balconies across all floors.
- The development fails to provide an active street frontage at Rosemount Lane, undermining the Letterkenny 2040 Regeneration Strategy, and provides substandard internal residential accommodation that does not comply with the 2022 Apartment Guidelines.
Cited Policies (CDP)
Policy UB-P-10Policy LK-TC-P-12Policy LK-TC-P-15Policy LK-TC-P-16Policy LK-TC-P-18Policy UB-P-12Policy BH-P-4Policy UB-P-7Objective CS-O-4Policy CS-P-1Policy CS-P-5Policy CS-P-6Objective UB-O-2Objective UB-O-4Objective UB-O-9Policy UB-P-2Policy UB-P-6Policy UB-P-13Policy UB-P-23
Decision Document Summary
The application relates to a 0.08ha brownfield site on Rosemount Lane, Letterkenny, currently containing derelict houses and outbuildings. The applicant proposed 17 apartments in a 4-to-5 storey block over basement parking. While the Inspector agreed that the existing buildings are not protected and their demolition is acceptable in the context of urban renewal, the proposed replacement was deemed unsuitable. The Inspector argued that the scale and bulk of the new building failed to respect the ...SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.