Core Refusal Reason
The proposed 24m lattice mast, located within the Newcastle Village Architectural Conservation Area and in close proximity to several Protected Structures, would have an unacceptable visual impact on the historic character and setting of the area and would adversely affect the visual amenity of the village.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The proposed 24m lattice tower is a bulky and utilitarian structure that is visually unsuited to the sensitive context of the Newcastle Architectural Conservation Area and its proximity to several Protected Structures.
- The applicant failed to adequately demonstrate that the proposed site represents a 'last resort' or that alternative locations and design options were fully explored to minimize impact on the historic village core.
- The reliance on existing vegetation for screening is considered unreliable as the specific trees identified are in poor condition and are likely to be removed due to permitted adjacent developments.
Cited Policies (CDP)
QDP3 Objective 1QDP3 Objective 2EDE13 Objective 2NCBH20 Objective 3NCBH20 Objective 5NCBH19 Objective 1NCBH19 Objective 2EI4 Objective 3Policy IE5IE5 Objective 1IE5 Objective 3IE5 Objective 4Section 12.11.2Section 12.11.3Section 12.11.5Objective IT07Objective IT08
Decision Document Summary
Vantage Towers Ltd. sought permission for a 24m lattice telecommunications mast at Landmark Architectural Salvage on Main Street, Newcastle, Co. Dublin. The proposal was refused by South Dublin County Council due to its location within an Architectural Conservation Area (ACA) and its proximity to Protected Structures like St. Finian's Church. The Inspector agreed with the refusal, noting that while there is a technical need for improved 4G/5G coverage, the scale and design of the mast would be v...SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.