Core Refusal Reason
The Planning Authority initially refused permission on the grounds that the development's high density and the specific form and design of the duplex units were out of character with the established pattern of development in the locality, potentially impacting residential amenity and contravening Sustainable Residential Development guidelines.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The proposed net density of approximately 43 units per hectare is considered appropriate for this transitional outer-suburban location and is consistent with the general range of 35-50 dwellings per hectare recommended in national guidelines.
- The revised 'Design Option 2' provides significant improvements to the scheme's layout, providing a graduation in height and acceptable side boundary setbacks that help assimilate the buildings into the surrounding context without compromising the amenity of existing residents.
- Although a shortfall in on-site public open space exists relative to the 15% target for greenfield sites, this is acceptable in the context of the site's constraints and can be appropriately mitigated via a financial contribution in lieu.
Cited Policies (CDP)
RA ZoningRS ZoningPolicy CSP34Objective CSO58Objective CIOSO5Objective CIOSO44Policy CMP2Policy CMP25Objective GINHO20Section 14.5.2Section 14.5.3Section 14.6Section 14.13Objective DMSO50Objective DMSO51Objective DMSO52Objective DMSO53Objective DMSO56Objective DMSO57Objective DMSO68Objective DMSO69Section 14.17Section 14.6.3Objective DMSO27
Decision Document Summary
This report pertains to a First Party appeal against the refusal of planning permission for a residential development on a 1.84ha greenfield site in Rush, Co. Dublin. The proposal originally sought 74 units but was amended during the application process to two options (66 or 62 units) following density and design concerns from Fingal County Council. The Inspector argues that the site is situated in an area transitioning from a traditional peripheral settlement edge to one of urban growth. The In...SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.