2250

permission for a development consisting of the construction of multi-operator telecommunications infrastructure comprised of: an 18m monopole (overall structure height of 19.5 metres), antennas, dishes and associated equipment, together with new ground level equipment cabinets. Significant further recieevd in relation to the submission of photomontages of the proposed telecommunications installation

Refused

Core Refusal Reason

The applicant failed to provide a sufficient visual impact assessment, failed to demonstrate technical necessity given existing coverage, and did not adequately explore co-location or alternative sites.

Decision Maker's Conclusion

  • The applicant failed to submit a commensurate visual impact assessment or account for the impact on surrounding Architectural Conservation Areas (ACAs) and nearby protected structures.
  • It was not conclusively demonstrated that the proposed 18m monopole would not unduly overshadow or have an overbearing impact on surrounding residential properties.
  • The technical justification for the structure was considered insufficient as the area already benefits from good coverage, and the potential for co-location at existing sites was not acceptably addressed.

Cited Policies (CDP)

Policy AAP 1Section 7.20Section 15.21Policy TCOP 1Policy TCOP 2Policy TCOP 3Section 6.17Policy RDP 24Policy TCOP 4Section 15.27

Decision Document Summary

Eir (Eircom Ltd.) proposed the construction of an 18m monopole (total height 19.5m) and associated telecommunications infrastructure in an alleyway behind the Eir telephone exchange on Mill Street, Monaghan Town. The application was refused by Monaghan County Council due to the lack of a visual impact assessment regarding its proximity to heritage assets and residential properties. Furthermore, the Planning Authority determined that the applicant had not sufficiently justified the need for a new...
SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.