Core Planning Reasoning
The proposed development is recommended for a grant of permission as it is consistent with the 'Objective A' zoning of the site, aligns with the Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Development Plan's Building Height and Housing Strategies, and is considered an appropriate densification of a serviced brownfield site at a strategic corner location on the N11 Core Bus Corridor without causing undue injury to the residential amenities of the area.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The principle of a 96-bedroom residential care facility is deemed acceptable on these residentially zoned lands, as it addresses a documented demographic need for older person's housing and utilizes a vacant, well-serviced brownfield site.
- While the six-storey height is a departure from the prevailing two-storey suburban character, it is justified by the site's strategic corner location and frontage onto the N11, and it is found that the design will not adversely impact the setting of the nearby Protected Structure or the Foxrock ACA.
- Concerns regarding residential amenity impacts, specifically overlooking and overbearance on properties like No. 1 Kill Lane and No. 53 Bray Road, can be successfully mitigated by conditions requiring an additional 1-meter setback for the north-eastern elevation, obscure glazing, and enhanced landscaping.
Cited Policies (CDP)
Zoning Objective 'A'Objective SNIPolicy Objective PHP30Policy Objective PHP9Section 12.3.8.2Section 12.8.4Policy Objective PHP19Section 3.4.1Policy Objective CA5Policy Objective CA7Policy Objective CA8Policy Objective CA10Policy Objective CA18Policy Objective CA17Policy Objective PHP35Policy Objective PHP42Appendix 5 (Building Height Strategy)Policy Objective BHS 1Policy Objective BHS 3Section 12.11.2.3Section 12.11.3Policy Objective T31Policy Objective PHP44Policy Objective T1Policy Objective T11Policy Objective T17Policy Objective T19Section 12.4.5Policy Objective T18Policy Objective T24Section 12.4.6Section 12.4.6.1Section 12.4.6.2Section 5.10Policy Objective T35Policy Objective PHP20Section 11.4.1.2 Policy Objective HER8Section 11.4.1.6 Policy Objective HER12Section 11.4.2.1 Policy Objective HER13Section 11.4.2.2 Policy Objective HER14Policy Objective CS14Section 2.6.2.1Policy Objective PHP25Section 12.3.1.1Section 12.3.5.2Section 10.4.2 Policy Objective EI15Section 10.4.1 Policy Objective EI14Section 12.9.3Section 12.4.8.3
Decision Document Summary
The proposal by Care Concern Group involves the demolition of two vacant detached houses (No. 51 Clara House and No. 52 Montrose) at the junction of Bray Road (N11) and Kill Lane in Foxrock, Dublin 18, to facilitate the construction of a 96-bedroom residential care facility. The proposed building is a part-4, part-5, and part-6 storey structure reaching a maximum height of 18.2m. The Planning Authority (Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council) granted permission, leading to a third-party appeal by...SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.
PDF Document Missing
The original decision document for this case could not be linked. This often happens for older cases or those with restricted documentation.
Search for case on ABP