2360

For a ten-year planning permission consisting of: I.) The felling/removal of some 343 hectares of conifer plantation for the purposes of peatland restoration and the establishment of native woodland. ii.) Measures to restore and rehabilitate approximately 281 hectares of Atlantic blanket bog and heathland that is currently planted with lodgepole pine and Sitka spruce forests and managed for commercial forestry. iii.) Conversion of 62 hectares of conifer forestry to native woodland. iv.) Main peatland restoration measures will include tree removal, drain blocking (manual and mechanical) and ground reprofiling. v.) The control of existing invasive species on site and continued control during the restoration works to prevent their spread. vi.) Drain-blocking all existing artificial drainage and artificial land drains currently existing within the peatland restoration areas in order to restore the high water table which is necessary for blanket bog growth. vii.) Provision of silt traps at outflows to block the pathway to the Twelve Bens/Garraun Complex Special Area of Conservation. viii.) Deer fencing to protect 62 hectares of proposed native woodland. ix.) Provision of a Harvest Management Phasing Plan for the proposed project. x.) Provision of new internal access road extending to 1.58 km. xi.) Across the site there will be 4 no. temporary water-crossings constructed in order to acilitate the harvesting of the timber at the site. xii.) Provision of informational signage. xiii.) Resurfacing of up to 8.23 km of existing forestry roads. xiv.) Resurfacing of existing car park to facilitate public access. xv.) Installation of water monitoring stations for real time water monitoring during operations. xvi.) Cutting of roadside trees to improved sightline visibility at site entrance. xvii.) The application is supported by an Environmental Impact Assessment Report (EIAR) and a Natura Impact Statement (NIS)

Refused

Core Refusal Reason

The application was refused due to insufficient information and assessment regarding environmental impacts on Natura 2000 sites, inadequate peat stability and flood risk analysis, and unresolved traffic safety concerns at the site entrance.

Decision Maker's Conclusion

  • The applicant failed to provide sufficient scientific evidence to rule out adverse effects on the integrity of European sites, specifically the Twelve Bens SAC and Connemara Bog Complex, due to untested restoration methodologies and potential water quality impacts.
  • The Environmental Impact Assessment Report (EIAR) contained significant gaps and inconsistencies regarding peat stability, flood risk, and comprehensive biodiversity surveys, preventing a full evaluation of the project's environmental effects.
  • The proposed development would result in a traffic hazard due to the intensification of an existing access onto the R344 regional road without demonstrating adequate sightlines or providing a satisfactory Traffic and Transport Assessment.

Cited Policies (CDP)

Policy Objective P2NR1NR2NNR2DM Standard 28DM Standard 33Policy Objective NR3DM Standard 31NHB 1NHB 2NHB 3NHB 4DM Standard 50WR 1

Decision Document Summary

This proposal by Coillte Teoranta involved a ten-year plan to fell 343 hectares of conifer plantation for peatland restoration and native woodland establishment at Derryclare and Cloonnacartan, Co. Galway. Situated in an 'Iconic' landscape adjacent to the Twelve Bens SAC, the project aimed to restore Atlantic blanket bog. However, the application was refused because the Planning Authority could not conclude that the development would not adversely affect the environment or public safety, citing ...
SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.