Core Refusal Reason
The proposed retention of the porch was refused because its suburban design, excessive size, and scale are considered incongruous with the character of the existing rural dwelling and the surrounding Area of High Amenity.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The porch's suburban design, featuring a flat roof and blockwork, is considered alien to the rural landscape and fails to complement the simple form of the existing semi-detached dwelling.
- The size and scale of the 14sqm extension are deemed excessive for this rural location, creating an obtrusive and obscure feature visible from the public road (L-5156-0).
- The development is contrary to the Single Rural Houses Guidelines and the landscape objectives for an Area of High Amenity, negatively impacting the visual amenities of the South East Mountain Lowlands.
Cited Policies (CDP)
Chapter 17: Natural Environment Section17.3 LandscapeAppendix 5 - Landscape Assessment (CDP 2016-2022)5.3.10 South East Mountain Lowland KDCAppendix 1 (Development and Design standards)Appendix 2 (Single Rural Houses Guidelines)Design Guidelines for Homes in Rural Wicklow
Decision Document Summary
This application sought the retention of a 14sqm single-storey entrance porch at Casimir Lodge, Kilboy, Kilbride, Co. Wicklow, a site located within a designated Area of High Amenity. While the principle of an extension was acceptable, Wicklow County Council refused permission due to the porch's contemporary suburban design and excessive scale. The planning authority determined that the flat-roofed structure was incongruous with the character of the existing rural dwelling and would form an obtr...SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.