2560225

for construction of an apartment development consisting of 4 apartments (3 No two bedroom apartments and 1 no. one bedroom apartment), construction of a single storey detached bin and bicycle building, entrance, car parking and landscaping and all associated site works. Revised by Significant Further Information which consists of: Revised changes to the proposed development which now consists of permission for construction of an apartment development consisting of 4 apartments (3 No. two bedroom apartments and 1 No. one bedroom apartment), entrance, car parking and landscaping and all associated site works. The apartment development has been redesigned and relocated on site as a request for further information

Refused

Core Refusal Reason

The proposed design and layout are considered inappropriate for the site context, characterized by a poor architectural response, a hipped roof out of character with the area, and a site layout dominated by surface car parking at the front.

Decision Maker's Conclusion

  • The architectural treatment, specifically the hipped roof and front elevation fenestration, fails to provide an innovative or modern design response and is out of character with the surrounding development.
  • The site layout is poorly configured, with the building line set back too far and the frontage dominated by car parking, which detracts from the visual amenity and fails to establish a proper streetscape.
  • The proposed units fail to meet the mandatory minimum standards for apartment developments regarding internal storage, floor areas, bedroom widths, and the provision of private open space.

Cited Policies (CDP)

Objective CS O1CS O13CS O19Policy HO P5HO P6HO P7Objective HO O6Policy TM P1Policy IN P4Objective IN O22Objective INO23INO24Policy IN P5Policy AH P2Policy BI P12Policy BI P13Policy BI P15Objective BI O78Policy UD P1Objective UD O1Section 15.2.2Section 15.2.4Section 15.4.6Section 15.6.6

Decision Document Summary

The proposal by Xhezaj Construction Ltd involves the construction of 4 apartments on a 0.075ha infill site at Naas Road, Newbridge, Co. Kildare. Although the site is appropriately zoned for residential infill, the Planning Authority found the current design and layout unacceptable. The primary grounds for concern include the inappropriate hipped roof design, the lack of architectural quality, the dominance of car parking at the site's front, and non-compliance with the 'Sustainable Urban Housing...
SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.