Core Refusal Reason
Failure to demonstrate compliance with Rural Housing Qualifying Criteria 5, specifically the necessity of a new dwelling over adapting the existing family home, combined with technical deficiencies in traffic safety, boundary preservation, and drainage design.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The applicant failed to adequately demonstrate that the existing family home could not be extended or modified to meet their residential needs, which is a mandatory requirement for qualifying under Criteria 5 of Rural Policy Zone 1.
- The proposal lacked sufficient detail to ensure the retention of historic stone walls on the site boundaries and failed to provide the required 3.0m x 75m visibility sightlines at the junction with the public road, presenting a traffic safety risk.
- Technical documentation for the proposed soakaway and wastewater treatment system contained significant errors and lacked the necessary certification to ensure compliance with environmental and public health standards.
Cited Policies (CDP)
HOU 40HOU 41HOU 42HOU 45HOU 46HOU 47NBG 24NBG 37NBG 50ENV 39MOV 56IU 16IU 17IU 18IU 19
Decision Document Summary
Suzanne & William Napier sought permission for a 143sqm 4-bedroom bungalow and wastewater treatment system at Aghnaskeagh, Mountpleasant, Co. Louth, a site located within Rural Policy Zone 1 (Area under Strong Urban Influence). While the applicant established a social connection to the area, the planning authority determined that the proposal did not satisfy the 'local need' criteria as it was not proven that the existing family home was unsuitable for adaptation. Furthermore, the application wa...SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.