Core Refusal Reason
The unauthorized and extensive demolition of significant portions of a protected structure without adequate justification, resulting in the potential irreversible loss of its historic and architectural character.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The works carried out, including the removal and reconstruction of the roof and additional walls, significantly exceeded the scope of the previously granted permission (PL 23/60243) and were not permitted in the original application.
- The applicant failed to provide a comprehensive technical assessment, structural justification, or conservation record to support the necessity of the extensive demolition of the historic fabric.
- The Planning Authority considers that the historic and architectural value of the protected structure has been significantly and potentially irreversibly compromised, creating an undesirable precedent for heritage protection within the County.
Cited Policies (CDP)
Chapter 11: Built and Cultural Heritage11.7.1 Protected StructuresChapter 16: Development Management Standards16.4.4 Residential Development14.4.20.1 Protected StructuresDMS 16.190
Decision Document Summary
The proposal sought retention permission for unauthorized works and design changes to Lismore House, a late 19th-century farmhouse and protected structure near Longford town, following the substantial demolition of its original fabric during a previously permitted refurbishment. Although a prior permission existed for a rear extension, the applicants undertook extensive additional removals, including the total replacement of the roof and various internal walls. The application was refused becaus...SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.