2660128
for development which will consist of the construction of telecommunications infrastructure comprised of; an 18 metre monopole support structure (21.1m overall structure height to top of omni antennas) carrying antennas, dishes and associated telecommunications equipment, together with new ground level equipment cabinets, fencing and all associated site works. The proposal includes the removal of an existing 10 metre wooden pole with emergency services equipment to be replaced onto the new support structure
Core Refusal Reason
The proposed development was refused due to its significant negative visual impact on a designated scenic route and its overbearing effect on adjacent residential properties, combined with a failure to provide sufficient technical justification for the site as a 'last resort' location.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The structure would be visually intrusive and dominant on the R352 designated Scenic Route, inherently altering the character of the eastern approach to Scarriff.
- The 21.1m monopole would have an overbearing and imposing effect on the residential amenities of the Derg View housing estate, which is located within 20 metres of the proposed site.
- The applicant failed to provide adequate technical justification to demonstrate that alternative sites at higher elevations were unavailable or that the subject site represents a 'last resort' as required by national guidelines.