2360337

extension of the existing limestone quarry and for continued use of the site entrance, access laneway, lagoons, plant and machinery and ancillary works. The extension area will be 0.869ha in lands directly north of the existing quarry. An Environmental Impact Assessment Report has been prepared and will be submitted with this application

Refused

Core Refusal Reason

The proposal was deemed premature and inadequately supported by environmental and technical data, specifically regarding the justification for a lateral extension while existing permitted capacity remains unexhausted, the lack of a comprehensive restoration plan, and insufficient assessment of cumulative traffic and hydrological impacts.

Decision Maker's Conclusion

  • The applicant failed to provide a detailed justification for extending the quarry footprint when substantial permitted extraction remains unexhausted on-site and restoration of existing worked-out areas has not yet commenced.
  • The Environmental Impact Assessment Report (EIAR) was found to be deficient in its assessment of cumulative impacts, particularly regarding the intensification of quarrying activities and the resulting HGV traffic hazards on the narrow L-8013 local road network.
  • Inadequate information was submitted to rule out significant adverse effects on the Lower River Suir SAC (002137), specifically concerning the hydrological connectivity established via the discharge of pumped groundwater into the Drish River.

Cited Policies (CDP)

Policy 8-7Policy 11-1Policy 11-2Policy 11-3Policy 11-4Policy 11-5Policy 11-7Policy 11-8Policy 11-9Policy 11-12Policy 11-16Policy 11-17Policy 11-18Policy 11-19

Decision Document Summary

Maher Quarries Ltd sought permission for a 0.869ha extension to an existing limestone quarry at Castletown, Moyne, Co. Tipperary. The proposal included the continued use of existing infrastructure and extraction to a depth of 15-17m below ground level. While the Planning Authority acknowledged the principle of mineral extraction under Policy 8-7, the application was refused due to significant concerns regarding site management and environmental protection. Key issues included the applicant's fai...
SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.