Core Refusal Reason
The retention of the viewing pod is recommended for refusal as it constitutes an inappropriate man-made intervention into a protected High Amenity landscape (Howth SAAO), resulting in the removal of protected maritime heathland and setting an undesirable precedent that undermines local planning policy and landscape conservation objectives.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The development is located within a highly sensitive High Amenity (HA) zone and the Howth SAAO, where strict policy protections exist to conserve natural character and maritime heathland from inappropriate development.
- The viewing pod, characterized by its masonry construction and requirement for significant excavation/earthworks, represents a new and incongruous structure that is out of character with the protected natural landscape.
- Granting retention permission would establish an unacceptable planning precedent that would undermine the integrity of the High Amenity zoning objective and the environmental protections afforded to the Howth Head area.
Cited Policies (CDP)
Fingal Development Plan 2023-2029Policy GINHP28Objective GINHO67Objective GINHO58Objective GINHO60Zoning Objective HA (High Amenity)Howth SAAO Objective 2.1Howth SAAO Objective 2.4Howth SAAO Policy 2.4.1Howth SAAO Policy 3.4.2
Decision Document Summary
The application seeks the retention of a 45sqm, partly subterranean viewing pod and associated site works at 'Cliff Haven', Thormanby Road, Howth. The site is a substantial residential plot positioned in a sylvan setting overlooking the Irish Sea, zoned 'High Amenity' and situated within the Howth Special Amenity Area Order (SAAO). The appellant argued the pod merely replaced a legacy timber structure and has minimal visibility from the public realm. However, the Inspector found that the masonry...SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.