24/4505

Permission to construct a new Licenced Discount Foodstore with ancillary infrastructure and associated site works. The development of the proposed Licenced Discount Food Store (2,493 sqm Gross Floor Space) will consist of: 1) A retail sales area with ancillary off-licence use and bakery (total net retail floorspace of 1,742 sqm), entrance pod, public facilities (incl. lobby and toilets), staff facilities (incl. welfare lobbies, toilets, cloak/change room, staff canteen, meeting room and operational office), IT room, plant room and area, delivery area and storage (incl. cold storage and Deposit Return Scheme facilites), rooftop photovoltaic solar panel array totalling 980 sqm, and external covered trolley bay with 8 no. bicycle parking spaces; corporate signage consisting of 2 no. building mounted corporate internally illuminated signs, 3 no. wall mounted externally illuminated billboards, 1 no. externally illuminated poster display board, and 2 no. free standing internally illuminated flagpole sign at vehicle entrance and public plaza area; 125 no. surface parking spaces ( 6 no. disabled, 4 no. parent and child, 2 no. EV charging, 100 no. regular car parking and 13 no. motorcycle) and 32 no. bicycle spaces ( 8 no long stay spaces and 24 no short stay spaces and 2)boundary treatments, hard and soft landscaping (incl. public plaza at the junction of Castlelake Avenue and Cork Road (L3678)), services (incl. site drainage accommodation works and underground surface water attenuation storage), ESB Substation (24.5sqm Gross Floor space), and all other ancillary infrastructure and associated site development works above and below ground level, 3) Primary vehicular and pedestrian access to the proposed Licenced Discount Foodstore will be provided via a new site entrance from Castlelake Avenue, and secondary pedestrian access will be provided via the proposed public plaza at the junction of Castlelake Avenue and Cork Road (L3678). The Planning application is accompanied by a Natura Impact Statement.

Refused

Core Refusal Reason

The proposal represents a piecemeal development with a generic design that fails to meet the specific zoning objectives and urban design requirements for a prominent town centre site.

Decision Maker's Conclusion

  • The development constitutes a piecemeal approach to the overall Town/Neighbourhood Centre zoning block rather than a comprehensive design response.
  • The generic design and surface car parking fail to respond to the site's prominence, context, and the urban design principles set out in the Retail Design Manual.
  • The proposal does not adequately integrate with existing active travel infrastructure or the required green infrastructure connections specified for the site.

Cited Policies (CDP)

CT-T-02TCR 9-19

Decision Document Summary

The application sought permission for a new licensed discount foodstore at a prominent location at the junction of Castlelake Avenue and Cork Road in Carrigtwohill. The site is zoned as part of a Town/Neighbourhood Centre (CT-T-02) in the Cork County Development Plan 2022, which requires careful consideration of design and connectivity. The planning authority refused the application because the generic design and surface parking layout were deemed inappropriate for such a significant gateway sit...
SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.