WEB1834/25
PROTECTED STRUCTURE PERMISSION and RETENTION for development at 36 Leinster Road, Rathmines, Dublin 6 a protected structure (PRS No. 4635). For Retention the development will consist of Internal Alterations, comprising of; Replacement of all MEP services to each unit using existing routes, Replacement of existing/previous modern partition walls with new partitions, in the same locations, where damp and signs of rot was present, Relocation of kitchenette in two of the existing units, Introduce breathable insulation lime-based finish to internal face of external walls. Carry out essential repairs to historic lime plaster and lath and plaster finish to internal partitions, For Planning the development will consist of Internal and External Alterations, comprising of; Insertion of new timber frame and sliding sash windows in existing window openings to the front and rear return. Install new door sets to entrance door opening of each unit to replace existing non-historic doors. Re-open door at the basement level and block up the existing door opening. Redecoration of historic staircase and interiors to main entrance hall using suitable breathable paints, Install insulation recycled foam aggregate to sub floor void of lower ground floor/basement level, Re-point externally exposed stone masonry walls of rear elevation and return using traditional lime mortar and Carry out thermal upgrades to internal side of the walls of the rear 1990s extension (non-historic).
Core Reason for the Refused Part
The Planning Authority issued a split decision, refusing retention permission for MEP services, partition walls, and kitchenette relocations on the grounds that these unauthorised works negatively impacted the historic fabric and special architectural character of the Protected Structure. However, the Inspector recommends granting permission for these elements, concluding they are minor alterations that do not cause new damage and facilitate the building's continued residential use.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The unauthorised works do not cause serious injury to the special architectural character or legibility of the Protected Structure and are considered minor material alterations.
- The suite of works results in a net positive impact by repairing damage (such as rot), reversing earlier inappropriate interventions, and ultimately conserving the structure for future residential use.
- The development is acceptable in terms of scale and nature and is in accordance with the proper planning and sustainable development of the area, subject to compliance with updated conditions.
Cited Policies (CDP)
Decision Document Summary
The application pertains to a Protected Structure at 36 Leinster Road, Rathmines, a three-storey terraced dwelling historically subdivided into eight bedsit units. The proposal includes retention and planning permission for a series of internal and external alterations, such as window replacements, MEP service upgrades, and partition repairs. While the Planning Authority refused aspects of the retention application due to concerns regarding the building's historic character, the Inspector argues...PDF Document Missing
The original decision document for this case could not be linked. This often happens for older cases or those with restricted documentation.
Search for case on ABP