SD21A/0155
Replace existing 12m decommissioned chimney flue with a 20m multi-user telecommunications support structure to include antennas and dishes and all enclosed within a shroud to match the existing decommissioned chimney flue; 2 outdoor cabinets and associated site works and a proposed new flue to replace an existing flue on an existing permitted building and accessed via the existing permitted access; the development will provide improved wireless broadband services in the area.
Core Refusal Reason
The proposed 20m telecommunications structure would result in a significant and negative visual impact on the immediate area, including public buildings and spaces, and would adversely affect the character and setting of the adjacent Protected Structure, Ballyroan Parish Church.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The 20m high structure cannot be absorbed into the existing urban environment without causing a significant negative impact on the visual amenity of the public courtyard and Marian Road.
- Insufficient evidence was provided to demonstrate that the mast would not visually compete with or detract from the spire of the adjacent Protected Structure, Ballyroan Parish Church.
- The development is contrary to national guidance (1996 Guidelines) which seeks to restrict such developments from sensitive residential and historic settings.