Core Refusal Reason
The proposed 30m lattice structure, due to its significant height and prominent location on an elevated site, would be a visually obtrusive and overbearing feature that would seriously injure the visual amenities and heritage assets of Rathmullan, an area designated for high scenic amenity.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The applicant failed to provide a robust justification for the site as a 'last resort' or demonstrate that the 30m lattice design was the most sensitive option for this specific elevated location.
- The structure would form a dominant and obtrusive feature on the skyline, adversely impacting the setting of local heritage assets, including the NIAH-rated St. Joseph's Church, and panoramic views of the Lough Swilly area.
- While the need for improved telecommunications infrastructure is supported by national and local policy, the significant visual injury to the historic and scenic character of Rathmullan outweighs the benefits of the proposal.
Cited Policies (CDP)
Policy CS-P-4Section 5.3Policy TC-O-1Policy TC-P-1Policy TC-P-3Policy TC-P-7Policy NH-P-7Policy NH-P-13
Decision Document Summary
Vantage Towers Limited proposed the construction of a 30-metre lattice telecommunications tower and associated infrastructure on an elevated site at Rathmullan & Ballyboe, Co. Donegal. The site is situated within the western margins of Rathmullan, a settlement categorized as an 'Historic Town' surrounded by areas of 'High Scenic Amenity.' Donegal County Council initially refused permission based on the structure's visual prominence near a primary school and residential properties, and the lack o...SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.