Core Refusal Reason
Donegal County Council refused permission on the grounds that the 24m lattice structure would be an overbearing and incongruous structure within a 'High Scenic Amenity' area, negatively impacting visual amenities and the character of the rural environment. However, the Inspector recommended granting permission, concluding that the development is justified by critical network requirements and that visual impacts are localized and mitigated by topography.
Decision Maker's Conclusion
- The proposed replacement structure is justified by the established need to improve 4G and emergency services coverage (Tetra Ireland) in a rural area with significant network deficiencies.
- While the lattice structure is larger than the existing monopole, its visual impact is localized and mitigated by the surrounding mountainous topography, coniferous forestry, and the existing utility use of the site.
- The proposal complies with national and local planning policies supporting the co-location of operators on established sites and the improvement of telecommunications infrastructure in rural areas.
Cited Policies (CDP)
TC-O-1TC-P-1TC-P-3TC-P-4TC-P-5TC-P-6NH-P-7NH-P-13Section 5.3Map 7.1.1
Decision Document Summary
The application by Eircom Limited (t/a eir) seeks to replace an existing 20m high monopole with a 24m lattice telecommunications structure (total height 27.1m) at the Eir Exchange in Drumaneany, Fintown, Co. Donegal. Donegal County Council initially refused permission, citing concerns that the structure would be overbearing in a landscape designated as High Scenic Amenity. The Inspector’s assessment found that the upgrade is essential for both commercial 4G services and critical national emergen...SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.