SD21A/0353

Retention permission for the existing telecommunications compound, including enclosure and ground mounted equipment; Permission for the replacement of a 25m high lattice tower with a new monopole carrying antennae, dishes and associated equipment with ground works, including foundation (overall height of 20m, excluding lightning finial).

Refused

Core Refusal Reason

While the Planning Authority refused permission based on unacceptable visual impacts in a central location and conflict with policies UC1 and UC2, the Inspector recommended a grant, concluding that the slim 20m monopole is a height reduction on an established utility site that does not materially harm visual amenity.

Decision Maker's Conclusion

  • The proposed 20m monopole represents a height reduction from the original mast and, given the site's established use as a utility compound, its contribution to visual clutter is considered minimal and acceptable.
  • The applicant has provided a reasonable technical justification for the location within the required geographical cell and successfully demonstrated a lack of viable alternative sites.
  • The development is compatible with the TC (Town Centre) zoning objective and complies with national guidelines regarding the provision of shared telecommunications infrastructure.

Cited Policies (CDP)

Policy UC1Policy UC2 Objective 2Objective TCPolicy IE5IE5 Objective 1IE5 Objective 3IE5 Objective 4IE5 Objective 7

Decision Document Summary

The application seeks retention of a telecoms compound and permission for a new 20m monopole at the ESB Substation on Ninth Lock Road, Clondalkin, to replace a previously removed 25m lattice tower. South Dublin County Council refused permission on the grounds that the structure would be overly prominent in a town centre setting. The Inspector, however, argues that the site is an established utility location and the slim design minimizes impact on nearby residential and commercial receptors, incl...
SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.