SD21A/0202

The setback, widening and relocation of a site entrance northwards along the public road, allowing for improved sight lines and it's repositioning, reordering and construction; a new pedestrian entrance; demolition of small shed/garage structure; filling-in of an existing swimming pool; demolition of a portion of the west flanking courtyard wall to re-establish a historic courtyard entrance ( as seen on Historic 6 Inch (1837-1842), Historic 25 inch (1888-1913) maps); construction of 11 residential units located surrounding Rookwood House (protected structure) on it's associated grounds, made up of Section 1: The Gate Lodge consisting of Unit 1, [1.5-Storey two bed, 4 person detached dwelling (83.50sq.m); Section 2: Mews Houses consisting of Units 2, 3 & 4, (two storey three bed, four person terraced dwellings (105.10sq.m) and Unit 5 (two Storey, three bed, six person detached dwelling (138.00sq.m) and Section 3: Woodland Houses consisting of Units 6 & 9 (2.5-storey, four bed, six person detached dwellings (152.00sq.m), Units 7 & 10 (2.5-storey, four bed, six person semi-detached dwellings (152.00sq.m) and Units 8 & 11 (2.5-storey, three bed, six person semi-detached dwellings (125.90sq.m) and maintaining the existing Rookwood house (protected structure) as a residential house, as is; 22 car parking spaces, new pedestrian footpaths, internal road network, detailed landscaping, services and all associated works.

Granted

Core Planning Reasoning

The Board directed the Planning Authority to retain Condition 3(e), which requires the provision of a pedestrian access/footpath to adjoining lands, to ensure future permeability and the creation of well-connected neighborhoods in accordance with sustainable development principles.

Decision Maker's Conclusion

  • The condition requiring a pedestrian link to adjoining lands is reasonable and necessary to facilitate future connectivity and avoid the proliferation of cul-de-sacs in the area.
  • While immediate implementation of a link depends on agreement between landowners, the site layout must be designed to facilitate such a connection to meet 'Active Travel' and '10-minute settlement' objectives.
  • The overall development of 11 residential units is acceptable in principle under the 'RES' zoning and represents a sensitive intensification of a site containing a protected structure.

Cited Policies (CDP)

Zoning Objective 'RES'Policy CS7CS7 Objective 1CS7 Objective 3Policy QDP1QDP1 Objective 4Policy QDP5QDP5 Objective 2Section 12.6.7

Decision Document Summary

This Inspector's Report evaluates a third-party appeal specifically regarding Condition 3(e) of a permission granted for 11 residential units on the grounds of Rookwood House (a Protected Structure) in Ballyboden, Dublin 16. The appellant, the owner of the adjoining 'Coolamber' site, objected to the requirement to provide a 1.8m wide pedestrian path to their boundary, arguing it was unnecessary and prejudicial to their own development layout. The Inspector analyzed the site context, noting that ...
SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.