3826/22

The proposed development will consist of the demolition of all structures on site, except No. 4 Sweeney's Terrace, and construction of a mixed use, primarily residential development comprising: A part 3, part 4 storey apartment block of 25 no. units (4 no. studio units, 8 no. 1 bed units, and 13 no. 2 bed units) over a partial basement level with ground floor terraces and upper floor balconies on the eastern, southern and western elevations. The proposed apartment block incorporates a dedicated bin storage area, substation and switch room at ground floor level, together with gated and controlled access to 2 no, external amenity areas comprising a communal courtyard to the east and a landscaped open space area along the partially culverted River Poddle to the south; and, A change of use of No. 4 Sweeney's Terrace from residential to office use, incorporating an extension at ground and first floor level to increase the Gross Floor Area (GFA) from approximately 81 sqm to 88sqm GFA, together with associated internal reconfiguration and modifications to elevations, A total of 69 no. bicycle parking spaces are proposed, consisting of 65 no. spaces for the apartment block (40 no. resident spaces, 3 no. cargo bike spaces and 22 no. visitor spaces) and 4 no. external bicycle parking spaces for the office use at No. 4 Sweeney's Terrace. 3 no. vehicle parking spaces are provided, consisting of 2 no. spaces to serve the apartment block ( 1 no. parking/set down to the north-west and 1 no. car-sharing space to the north-east) and the use of 1 no. existing space to the west of No. 4 Sweeney's Terrace to serve the proposed office use. The proposed development incorporates all associated site and development works, landscaping, boundary treatments and public lighting, together with remedial works to an exposed area of the River Poddle channel in the south-western part of the site (to match previously approved works on an adjoining site to the east under An Bord Pleanala Reg. Ref. ABP-303436-19) and the culverting of a small exposed area of the River Poddle adjoining the south-western boundary. Public access to the landscaped open space to the south of the proposed apartment block along the partially culverted River Poddle will be limited to daylight hours.

Granted

Core Planning Reasoning

The Inspector recommends a grant of permission, concluding that the revised 3-4 storey proposal successfully addresses the previous reasons for refusal regarding height and overbearance, integrating appropriately with the surrounding urban fabric while contributing to housing supply on an underutilised Z10 zoned site.

Decision Maker's Conclusion

  • The substantial reduction in height from the previously refused seven-storey scheme provides an appropriate transition between the taller developments to the north/east and the lower-rise dwellings on Sweeney's Terrace and Clarence Mangan Road.
  • The proposed residential amenity impacts regarding daylight, sunlight, and overlooking have been sufficiently mitigated through design revisions and are considered acceptable within the site's central urban context.
  • A zero-car parking provision is justified given the site's high accessibility to public transport and local amenities, and the revised swept path analysis demonstrates that vehicular and emergency access can be safely managed.

Cited Policies (CDP)

Z10: Inner Suburban and Inner City Sustainable Mixed-UsesSection 15.9.1 (Unit Mix)Policy CA3 (Climate Resilient Settlement Patterns)Policy CA8 (Climate Mitigation)Policy CA9 (Climate Adaptation)Policy CA24 (Waste Management)Policy CA27 (Flood Risk)Policy SC5 (Urban Design)Policy SC10 (Urban Density)Policy SC11 (Compact Growth)Policy SC12 (Housing Mix)Policy SC14 (Building Height)Policy SC19 (High Quality Architecture)Policy QHSN1 (National and Regional Policy)Policy QHSN6 (Urban Consolidation)Policy QHSN10 (Urban Density)Policy QHSN36 (High Quality Apartment Development)Policy QHSN37 (Homes and Apartments)Policy SMT27 (Car Parking)Section 15.4 (Key Design Principles)Section 15.8 (Residential Development)Section 15.9 (Apartment Standards)Appendix 3 (Achieving Sustainable Growth)Appendix 16 (Sunlight and Daylight)

Decision Document Summary

The proposal involves the demolition of vacant industrial structures on a 0.192-hectare brownfield site in 'The Liberties', Dublin 8, to construct a 25-unit apartment block ranging from three to four storeys. The plan includes the change of use of No. 4 Sweeney's Terrace from residential to office space and significant site works, including repairs to the River Poddle boundary. The site is zoned Z10 for sustainable mixed-use development. The Inspector's assessment highlights that this new applic...
SOURCE PDFOpen Original
Note: If code appears below, the council site is blocking the preview. Please open the original file.

PDF Document Missing

The original decision document for this case could not be linked. This often happens for older cases or those with restricted documentation.

Search for case on ABP